Potbelly Cookies Menu

You’re wrapping up lunch at a Potbelly shop, glancing at the counter for something sweet to finish off your sandwich or soup, but wondering if a cookie will hit the spot without adding too many calories or stretching your budget.

This 2026 Potbelly cookies menu guide delivers, featuring the warm Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie at $2.79, classic Sugar Cookie at $2.79, rich Chocolate Brownie Cookie at $2.79, chewy Dream Bar at $2.59, a Bag of Mini Cookies for $5.69, and the 6-Pack Cookie Box at $11.99, with calories around 420 for the box.

Potbelly Cookies Menu Inside, you’ll find details on ingredients, pricing, nutrition, and allergens (including wheat, dairy, and eggs), plus pairing ideas with drinks or sides, ordering options, and customer favorites. Potbelly Cookies Menu If you’re craving a dessert that perfectly complements your meal, this guide offers tips, tables, and Q&A to help you choose the ideal sweet treat.

$11.99 420 cal

6-Pack Cookie Box

Pick six of your favorite cookies or enjoy a mixed assortment of Potbelly’s freshly baked classics

$2.79 –

Diet Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie
Coke

A freshly baked cookie packed with hearty oats and rich chocolate chips for a warm, comforting treat.

$2.79 –

Sugar Cookie

A soft, classic sugar cookie baked fresh daily with a light, buttery sweetness.

$2.79 –

Chocolate Brownie Cookie

A rich, fudgy chocolate brownie style cookie, baked fresh daily for a deep cocoa flavor.

$2.59 –

Dream Bar

A rich, chocolatey oatmeal bar layered with sweet caramel for a perfectly chewy, indulgent bite.

$5.69 –

Bag of Mini Cookies

A dozen bite-sized oatmeal chocolate chip cookies, freshly baked and perfect for sharing or snacking.

Why Choose Potbelly Cookies?

Potbelly Cookies Menu We’ve all had those moments when a meal just doesn’t feel complete without something sweet, yet choosing between a warm cookie or a chewy dessert bar can feel tricky especially when you’re watching calories or planning to share. Potbelly Cookies Menu makes that decision easy with freshly baked treats that pair perfectly with salads, sandwiches, or drinks. From classic oatmeal chocolate chip cookies to indulgent bars, options start at $2.59, making them ideal for a quick personal treat or a shareable 6-pack when you want a little extra sweetness at the table.

What Cookies Are on the Potbelly Menu

Potbelly Cookies Menu Curious about what’s baking this year? The 2026 Potbelly cookies menu includes Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Sugar Cookie, and Chocolate Brownie Cookie at $2.79 each, the Dream Bar at $2.59, a Bag of Mini Cookies with a dozen pieces for $5.69, and the 6-Pack Cookie Box at $11.99 where you can mix and match favorites. These treats pair perfectly with drinks, soups, or sandwiches, turning dessert into a highlight of your meal.

Detailed Breakdown of Each Cookie

Potbelly Cookies Menu is all about fresh-baked comfort, with prices ranging from $2.59 to $11.99 and the 6-pack totaling around 420 calories. Here’s a quick guide to help you choose.

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

A warm, chewy cookie packed with oats and chocolate chips. At $2.79, it’s a classic choice alongside any drink.

Sugar Cookie

Soft, buttery, and baked fresh daily with a light sweetness. Priced at $2.79, it’s simple and satisfying.

Chocolate Brownie Cookie

A rich, fudgy chocolate cookie with deep cocoa flavor. For $2.79, it’s perfect with coffee or milk.

Dream Bar

A chewy oatmeal bar layered with chocolate and sweet caramel. At $2.59, it’s a standout treat.

Bag of Mini Cookies

A dozen mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookies, great for snacking or sharing. Priced at $5.69.

6-Pack Cookie Box

Pick six favorite cookies or an assorted mix, totaling about 420 calories. At $11.99, it’s ideal for groups.

Which Potbelly Cookie Is Best for Healthy Eating?

If you want a lighter option, the Sugar Cookie is a good pick, offering a simpler recipe with less chocolate or caramel compared to other choices.

Nutrition and Price Comparison in Potbelly Cookies Menu

Use a comparison table to easily review prices, calories, and which cookie best fits your cravings.

Potbelly Cookies Menu Calories are estimated based on similar baked goods, and allergens have been confirmed for each item.

Customize Your Cookie

Mix and match cookies in the 6-pack for variety, or grab the mini cookies for portion control.
Q: Can I make a lower-sugar choice?
A: The Sugar Cookie is the best option for a lighter, less sweet treat.

Tips for Enjoying Cookies

Warm an Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie with a shake for a melty, indulgent treat.
Share a 6-pack with friends during lunch.
Pair a Dream Bar with a soda for a sweet and contrasting flavor.

Pairing Ideas for a Full Meal

Enhance your meal by pairing an Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie with Chili Mac or a Sugar Cookie with a turkey sandwich and a soft drink. The 6-pack is perfect for sharing with groups.

Ordering Made Easy: Delivery, Locations, and Hours

Order in-store (typically 10 AM–9 PM, hours may vary), via the app for pickup, or through delivery.
Q: What’s the fastest way to get cookies?
A: Ordering through the app during off-peak hours is quickest.

Why Potbelly Cookies Stand Out

Fans love the $2.59–$2.79 fresh-baked cookies, which beat store-bought options in taste and quality. Fresh ingredients and variety build customer trust.

FAQs: Your Questions Answered

What cookies are on the Potbelly menu in 2026?

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Sugar Cookie, Chocolate Brownie Cookie, Dream Bar, Bag of Mini Cookies, and 6-Pack Cookie Box prices start at $2.59.

Which Potbelly cookie is best for healthy eating?

The Sugar Cookie, estimated at 150–200 calories, offers a lighter sweet option.

What ingredients are in the Dream Bar?

A chewy oatmeal bar with caramel and chocolate chips, around 200–250 calories.

How many calories are in the 6-Pack Cookie Box?

Approximately 420 calories for six cookies, depending on your selection.

Your Next Step

Potbelly Cookies Menu delights with fresh-baked treats, perfect for dessert or a sweet snack. Order in-store, try delivery, or pick up a 6-pack to share. Treat yourself today!