Potbelly Pizza Melt Sandwich: Tasty Gem in 625 Calories

The Potbelly Pizza Melt Sandwich is a pizza-inspired, signature menu item. Priced at $11.29 and containing 625 calories, it features pepperoni, old-world capicola, crumbled meatball, mushrooms, marinara sauce, provolone cheese, and Italian seasoning on toasted bread. A vegetarian version is also available. This zesty, bold-flavored sandwich is perfect for lunch and pairs well with chips, a salad, or a chocolate shake for a complete meal at your local Potbelly shop. Curious about the ingredients, how to make it, or what Italian seasoning Potbelly uses? Keep reading to learn more about toppings, nutrition, and why fans love this classic. Discover more at The Potbelly Menu.

$11.29 625 cal

Pizza Melt

A pizza-inspired sandwich with pepperoni, old-world capicola, crumbled meatball, mushrooms, provolone cheese, and Italian seasoning, all smothered in marinara sauce. Vegetarian option available.

You Crave a Pizza-Inspired, Flavorful Lunch

You’re looking for a lunch that captures pizza’s bold, savory flavors in a sandwich, without feeling greasy or heavy. If you’re tracking points or calories, you might ask, Is a Pizza Melt sandwich from Potbelly healthy? or How many calories are in a Potbelly Pizza Melt? You want quality ingredients like pepperoni, marinara, and provolone, with a vegetarian option, that balance flavor with nutrition and are easy to order for yourself or a group.

We Understand Lunch Should Be Tasty and Fun

We’ve all had those days when a plain sandwich or light salad doesn’t satisfy. You want a meal that delivers pizza-like flavors with fresh ingredients, whether grabbing a quick bite or feeding a team. Lunch should excite your taste buds while fitting your dietary preferences, including vegetarian or lighter options.

The Solution: Potbelly Pizza Melt Sandwich

The Pizza Melt sandwich is your answer for a zesty, pizza-inspired lunch. This Potbelly original combines pepperoni, old-world capicola, crumbled meatball, mushrooms, marinara, provolone cheese, and Italian seasoning on toasted bread. Make it vegetarian by skipping the meats. Order at a Potbelly shop or online for a meal that hits all the right notes.

Main Ingredients

What comes on a Potbelly Pizza Melt sandwich? Premium ingredients create a pizza-like experience:

• Pepperoni – spicy, bold
• Old-world capicola – rich, flavorful
• Crumbled meatball – savory, hearty
• Marinara sauce – tangy, robust
• Provolone cheese – creamy, melted
• Mushrooms – earthy, fresh
• Italian seasoning – aromatic signature blend
• Toasted bread – crispy, warm

For a vegetarian option, omit the meats while keeping the cheese, mushrooms, marinara, and seasoning.

Toppings & Add-Ons

Customize your Pizza Melt with Potbelly’s menu options:

Pro Tip: Add banana peppers for a tangy, zesty kick that complements the marinara.

Flavor and Texture: A Pizza-Inspired Delight

The Pizza Melt is a flavor-packed sandwich. Pepperoni, capicola, and meatball blend with tangy marinara and melted provolone for a rich, pizza-like bite. Mushrooms add an earthy layer, and Italian seasoning brings zesty depth. Toasted bread gives a warm, crispy texture, making it distinct from other menu items like the Italian or Cubano sandwiches.

Allergen & Dietary Notes

Is a Pizza Melt sandwich from Potbelly healthy? It depends on your goals. A standard sandwich has 625 calories, 34g protein, 30g fat, 52g carbs, and about 1400mg sodium. For a lighter option, go vegetarian (skip meats) or choose a salad-style version. Allergens include dairy (cheese) and gluten (bread). Full nutrition details are in the Potbelly Menu PDF.

How to Make a Potbelly Pizza Melt Sandwich

• Gather Ingredients: Pepperoni, old-world capicola, crumbled meatball (or cooked ground beef), marinara, provolone, mushrooms, and a crusty roll. Italian seasoning can be made with oregano, basil, thyme, and garlic powder.
• Prep: Slice mushrooms; cook meatball if using raw beef.
• Toast Bread: Lightly toast at 350°F for 3–5 minutes.
• Assemble: Spread marinara, layer meats (optional), cheese, mushrooms, and sprinkle Italian seasoning.
• Finish: Toast 2–3 minutes until cheese melts; serve warm.

Pairing Your Pizza Melt Sandwich: Build a Complete Meal

Add sides to make a full lunch: chips for crunch, mac and cheese for extra comfort, soups like minestrone or tomato, a salad for freshness, and a chocolate shake to finish.

Suggested Pairings:

• Chips: Zapp’s
• Soups: Tomato
• Salads: Farmhouse
• Shake: Chocolate

The Story of the Pizza Melt Sandwich

A pizza-inspired classic from Potbelly’s Chicago sandwich shop roots, packed with bold flavors and a vegetarian option. Fans love it for its pizza-like taste in a convenient sandwich format.

Why Fans Love the Pizza Melt Sandwich

It’s like a pizza in a sandwich perfect lunch, says one fan. Another adds, The marinara and mushrooms make it amazing.

Order Your Pizza Melt Sandwich Today

Visit a Potbelly shop or order online for pickup or delivery. Customize with toppings and check nutrition details to fit your goals.

Conclusion

The Pizza Melt, priced at $11.29 with 625 calories, blends pepperoni, capicola, crumbled meatball, mushrooms, marinara, provolone, and Italian seasoning on toasted bread. Vegetarian option available. Pair with sides or a shake for a complete, bold-flavored meal.

FAQs About the Pizza Melt Sandwich

What is a Pizza Melt sandwich at Potbelly?

A pizza-inspired sandwich with meats, cheese, marinara, mushrooms, and Italian seasoning, priced at $11.29 with 625 calories.

What comes on a Potbelly Pizza Melt sandwich?

Pepperoni, old-world capicola, crumbled meatball, marinara sauce, provolone cheese, mushrooms, Italian seasoning, on toasted bread.

How many calories in a Potbelly Pizza Melt sandwich?

625 calories, with 34g protein, 30g fat, 52g carbs.

Is a Pizza Melt sandwich from Potbelly healthy?

It’s protein-rich but has 625 calories and 1400mg sodium. Go vegetarian or salad-style for a lighter option.